Ecce Verbum
904 subscribers
883 photos
8 videos
308 files
631 links
Catholic reading material archive
Download Telegram
Ecce Verbum
Tertullian and the heresy of Montanism Collection of excerpts: "Quintus Septimius Florens Tertullian (155-245 A.D.) was born to pagan parents in Carthage, North Africa between 155-160 A.D. A lawyer by profession, he converted to Christianity in 193 A.D.…
What did the Fathers of the Early Church think of Tertullian?

"Today, Tertullian (c. AD 155–240) has something of a mixed reputation in many Christian circles. He's recognized as a significant thinker and a major contributor to the doctrine of the Trinity. But in his later years he became associated with a movement known as Montanism, and he seems to have separated himself from the church."

"In antiquity most Christians never forgave him for his apostasy (rejection of his earlier faith) to Montanism. Later Christian writers mention him only infrequently and then mostly unfavourably. Somewhat grudgingly, however, they acknowledged his literary gifts and acute intelligence. Modern scholars, however, do not share this earlier view. Since the 19th century Tertullian has been widely read and studied and is considered one of the formative figures in the development of Christian life and thought in the West."

"As a result of this and some of his teachings, he is not recognized as a saint in Catholicism. Today, Tertullian has something of a mixed reputation in many Christian circles."

Like today, those in the early church had differing opinions regarding Tertullian. Some were largely critical, some largely complimentary, and some more balanced.

The first writings we have discussing Tertullian are decidedly in the first category – their author, Lactantius (c. 250–325), was dismissive of him:

"Septimius Tertullianus also was skilled in literature of every kind; but in eloquence he had little readiness, and was not sufficiently polished, and very obscure." (Divine Institutes, 5.1)

"Although Tertullian fully pleaded the same cause in that treatise which is entitled the Apology, yet, inasmuch as it is one thing to answer accusers, which consists in defence or denial only, and another thing to instruct, which we do." (5.4)

Following Lactantius we might turn next to Eusebius (c. 260–340) and Jerome (c. 347–420). Eusebius emphasizes Tertullian's credibility, calling him "especially distinguished in Rome" (Church History, 2.2; cf. 2.25, 3.20, 3.33, 5.5), while Jerome focuses on his influence on Cyprian (c. 200–258) and his "lapse" into Montanism:
"
He was presbyter of the church until middle life, afterwards driven by the envy and abuse of the clergy of the Roman church, he lapsed to the doctrine of Montanus, and mentions the new prophecy in many of his books." (Lives of Illustrious Men, 53)

"I myself have seen a certain Paul an old man of Concordia, a town of Italy, who, while he himself was a very young man had been secretary to the blessed Cyprian who was already advanced in age. He said that he himself had seen how Cyprian was accustomed never to pass a day without reading Tertullian, and that he frequently said to him, "Give me the master," meaning by this, Tertullian. He was presbyter of the church until middle life, afterwards driven by the envy and abuse of the clergy of the Roman church, he lapsed to the doctrine of Montanus, and mentions the new prophecy in many of his books." (Lives of Illustrious Men, 53)

Historians agree that Cyprian was greatly influenced by Tertullian; see, for example, Everett Ferguson, Church History, 7.I.B.

Augustine (354–430) briefly writes of him in On Heresies, acknowledging his "many eloquent works" and defending his doctrine of the soul, before explaining his heresy:

"Therefore, the reason Tertullian became a heretic was [...] because in joining the Cataphrygians, whom he had earlier demolished, he also began to condemn, contrary to Apostolic teaching, second marriage as debauchery. Later, having separated from them too, he established congregations of his own." (On Heresies, 86)
Ecce Verbum
Tertullian and the heresy of Montanism Collection of excerpts: "Quintus Septimius Florens Tertullian (155-245 A.D.) was born to pagan parents in Carthage, North Africa between 155-160 A.D. A lawyer by profession, he converted to Christianity in 193 A.D.…
Finally we come to Vincent of Lerins (d. 445). In his treatment of Tertullian one can sense both his admiration and frustration:

"For who more learned than he, who more versed in knowledge whether divine or human? [...] Was not his genius of such unrivalled strength and vehemence that there was scarcely any obstacle which he proposed to himself to overcome, that he did not penetrate by acuteness, or crush by weight? As to his style, who can sufficiently set forth its praise? It was knit together with so much cogency of argument that it compelled assent, even where it failed to persuade."

"Yet this man also, notwithstanding all that I have mentioned, this Tertullian, I say, too little tenacious of Catholic doctrine, that is, of the universal and ancient faith, more eloquent by far than faithful, changed his belief, and justified what the blessed Confessor, Hilary, writes of him, namely, that "by his subsequent error he detracted from the authority of his approved writings." He also was a great trial in the Church." (Commonitory, 18)


Summary:
So we find then that, not unlike today, some in the first five centuries of the church had little regard for Tertullian (Lactantius), some were largely positive (Eusebius and Jerome), and others recognizing his merits while unable to defend his faults (Augustine and Vincent). His influence on Latin Christianity was not always admitted (e.g., in Cyprian and Hilary), but his errors were significant enough that they were rarely ignored.

Sources:
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14520c.htm
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tertullian
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10521a.htm
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Montanism
https://www.tertullian.org/montanism.htm

#churchfathers
Ecce Verbum
• Finally we come to Vincent of Lerins (d. 445). In his treatment of Tertullian one can sense both his admiration and frustration: "For who more learned than he, who more versed in knowledge whether divine or human? [...] Was not his genius of such unrivalled…
Montanists- Schismatics of the second century

First known as Phrygians, or "those among the Phrygians" (oi kata Phrygas), then as Montanists, Pepuzians, and (in the West) Cataphrygians. The sect was founded by a prophet, Montanus, and two prophetesses, Maximilla and Prisca, sometimes called Priscilla.The sect gained much popularity in Asia. It would seem that some Churches were wholly Montanist.

St Jerome describes them as such :
"They close the door of the Church to almost every sin. They say that God, not being able to save the world by Moses and the Prophets, took flesh of the Virgin Mary, and in Christ, His Son, preached and died for us. And because He could not accomplish the salvation of the world by this second method, the Holy Spirit descended upon Montanus, Prisca, and Maximilla, giving them the plenitude which St. Paul had not (1 Corinthians 13:9)."

"It soon became clear, however, that the Montanist prophecy was new. True prophets did not, as Montanus did, deliberately induce a kind of ecstatic intensity and a state of passivity and then maintain that the words they spoke were the voice of the Spirit."

In addition to prophetic enthusiasm, Montanism taught a legalistic moral rigorism. The time of fasting was lengthened, followers were forbidden to flee from martyrdom, marriage was discouraged, and second marriages were prohibited."

"When it became obvious that the Montanist doctrine was an attack on the Catholic faith, the bishops of Asia Minor gathered in synods and finally excommunicated the Montanists, probably c. 177. Montanism then became a separate sect with its seat of government at Pepuza."

"It continued in the East until severe legislation against Montanism by Emperor Justinian I (reigned 527–565) essentially destroyed it, but some remnants evidently survived into the 9th century."

"Responses to this were quite mixed in the church. After all, prophecy was a genuine gift of God, according to the New Testament."

"A reading of the anti-Montanist writers in Eusebius' Church History reveals a great deal of uncertainty among Christians at all levels as to whether the new prophecy was genuine or not. It seems also possible that Montanism in its homeland may have been heretical, but that it masked a genuine move of the Holy Spirit which in other places was entirely orthodox, and would today be regarded as pentecostal."

"It was in Carthage in Africa, however, that the sect became important. There, its most illustrious convert was Tertullian, who became interested in Montanism c. 206 and finally left the Catholic Church in 212–213."

"Tertullian fiercely attacks those who condemned the new prophecy, and in attacking the church authorities, he foreshadows the protestant reaction to papal claims."

"The Montanist writings have perished, except for brief references preserved by ecclesiastical writers. The chief sources for the history of the movement are Eusebius’ Historia ecclesiastica (Ecclesiastical History), the writings of Tertullian and Epiphanius, and inscriptions, particularly those in central Phrygia."


Sources:
https://www.tertullian.org/montanism.htm
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10521a.htm
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Montanism

#heresies
Telegram Archive

•library sites and telegram channels
prepping, practical skills

I've created a small index of library/archive channels and websites which I know of.

Feel free to contribute to expanding this list (all suggestions made in the comments are welcome), so that all of us can find it of use.

To find all archieved lists on this channel use
#index


channels

https://t.me/HomeschoolEducation

https://t.me/boogbooks

https://t.me/ulrichhirschmannarchives

https://t.me/forbiddenbookclub

https://t.me/OffTheGridOfficial

https://t.me/offgriddownload

https://t.me/practicalinformation

https://t.me/whatchadoinrabbibooks

https://t.me/based_books

https://t.me/BunkerDocumentaries

https://t.me/ImperivmLibrary

https://t.me/JohnnyGatArchive

https://t.me/PhoilHATS

https://t.me/The_Documentary_Channel

https://t.me/FashBooks

https://t.me/hederashomestead

https://t.me/DisclosureLibrary

https://t.me/WhiteNationalistLibrary

https://t.me/mysticallibrary

https://t.me/Bunker_Audio

https://t.me/CorbettReport

https://t.me/PreppersandSurvivalistLibrary

https://t.me/OPUSaudiobooks

https://t.me/TheBlackLibary

https://t.me/ClosedReserve

https://t.me/HomesteadingSelfSufficiency

websites

www.refseek.com - Academic Resource Search. More than a billion sources: encyclopedia, monographies, magazines.

www.worldcat.org - a search for the contents of 20 thousand worldwide libraries. Find out where lies the nearest rare book you need.

https://link.springer.com - access to more than 10 million scientific documents: books, articles, research protocols.

www.bioline.org.br is a library of scientific bioscience journals published in developing countries.

http://repec.org - volunteers from 102 countries have collected almost 4 million publications on economics and related science.

www.science.gov is an American state search engine on 2200+ scientific sites. More than 200 million articles are indexed.

www.pdfdrive.com is the largest website for free download of books in PDF format. Claiming over 225 million names.

www.base-search.net is one of the most powerful researches on academic studies texts. More than 100 million scientific documents, 70% of them are free.

https://www.liberatedmanuals.com/all.mpl
all free government manuals

https://www.logsa.army.mil/#/psmag
Current PS magazine issues

http://psmag.radionerds.com/index.php/Index_by_issue
Past PS magazine issues

https://armypubs.army.mil/ProductMaps/PubForm/ActiveInactiveRescSearch.aspx
Current FMs, STPs, etc

http://www.survivalebooks.com/usmilitarymanuals.html
Older manuals

https://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/USA/ref/FM/index.html
WW2 era manuals

https://usacac.army.mil/organizations/mccoe/call/publications
Current CALL handbooks

https://www.dxzone.com/catalog/Radio_Equipment/Radio_Manuals/
Radio Manuals

http://www.survivorlibrary.com/index.php/library-download
Old subject knowledge books

https://the-eye.eu/public/murdercube.com/
field manuals, survival

http://www.zetatalk11.com/docs/
massive library of prepping and survival documents (1'000's of pdf's)

https://www.freebookcentre.net/medical_text_books_journals/medical_text_books_online.html
Medical textbooks

https://www.ag.ndsu.edu/extension-aben/buildingplans/crops
Crops, farming build plans

https://www.theprepperjournal.com/resources/#
prepper links and resources

http://www.ps-survival.com/PS/index.htm
A lot of topics but it doesnt have a proper index.

https://archive.org/details/folkscanomy_prepper?&sort=-downloads&page=8
prepper's archieve

•survival Wiki
http://tspwiki.com/index.php?title=Main_Page
Prayer for the Church and for souls

(Recommended for frequent recitation in the present critical times)

O glorious Prince of the heavenly host, St Michael the Archangel, defend us in the battle and in the fearful warfare we are waging against the principalities and powers, against the rulers of this world of darkness, against the evil spirits. Come thou to the assistance of men, whom Almighty God created immortal, making them in His own image and likeness and redeeming
them at a great price from the tyranny of satan.

Fight this day the battle of the Lord with thy legions of holy Angels, even as of old thou didst fight against Lucifer, the leader of the proud spirits and all his rebel angels, who were powerless to stand against thee, neither was their place found any more in Heaven. And that apostate angel, transformed into an angel of darkness who still prowls about the earth to encompass our ruin, was cast headlong into the abyss together with his followers.

But behold, that first enemy of mankind, a murderer from the beginning, has regained his confidence. Changing himself into “an angel of light,” he goes about with the whole multitude of wicked spirits to invade the earth and to blot out the Name of God and of His Christ, to plunder, to slay and to consign to eternal damnation the souls that have been destined for a crown of everlasting life. This wicked serpent, like an unclean torrent, pours into men of depraved minds and corrupt hearts the poison of his malice, the spirit of lying, impiety and blasphemy, and the deadly breath of impurity and every form of vice and iniquity.

These crafty enemies of mankind have filled to overflowing with gall and wormwood the Church, which is the Bride of the Lamb without spot; they have laid profane hands upon her most sacred treasures.

Make haste, therefore, O invincible Prince, to help the People of God against the inroads of the lost spirits, and grant us the victory.
Amen.


#prayer
Above all else, we ought to reform ourselves

"Isn't it beautiful, this ideal of life ? The battle to conquer the whole world, the hearts of all men and of each one in particular, beginning with oneself. Our strength consists of recognising our own stupidity, weakness and misery, and entrusting ourselves entirely to the goodness and power of the Immaculata."

St. Maximilian Maria Kolbe, Letter, December 11, 1930

"What does it matter if you can win a thousand battles if you cannot win against your own corrupt passions ?
It doesn't matter. The real battle is with ourselves."

Bl. Carlo Acutis

"You wish to reform the world? Reform yourself. Otherwise your efforts will be vain."

St. Ignatius Loyola
Autodidacticism - #SolutionsWatch - The Corbett Report

Who said education was boring? On the contrary. Knowing more about the world, improving your skills and achieving success is electrifying and addictive. But first you have to learn how to learn. Autodidacticism is the process of learning about a skill or a subject without a formal teacher, and today Richard Grove of
GetAutonomy.info is here to help us get started on the lifelong quest of self-improvement and self-learning.

https://www.corbettreport.com/autodidacticism/

#education
Ecce Verbum
What is a Father 2. Fatherhood- a life of prayer and servitude ..Then the husband and the wife walk out of the church to see each other through life to eternal life. Their life together is to be a prayer-a sacrament; a sacramental way of life, as a priest's…
What is a Father

3.The father is an example


...All this time, the husband, almost always, grows more admirable and lovable in the eves of his wife. His goodness, character, dependability, and the things that grow out of real goodness-courtesy, consideration, understanding, and above all, tenderness.
It is a rare woman who does not respond to tenderness as a flower to the sun; who is not made singingly happy by strength united with gentleness in her husband.

The father who turns to prayer and to the sources of grace in the sacraments discovers-especially if he does it while his children are still young-that he is loved and respected and imitated, and that his home life grows happier. And kindness and goodness, once begun in a home, are passed along through the generations, with incalculable benefit to the world.

But, above all, the father is an example. It is impossible to exaggerate how impressionable young people are. Their eyes and ears and sensitivities are wide open.
If they live in an atmosphere of purity of speech and attitude and behaviour, purity will be a shiningly attractive thing to them. If they see a tenderness amounting to reverence between their father and mother, at least half the battle for their own success in marriage will have been won. A daughter whose father is considerate of her mother will seek a considerate husband for herself when the time comes. She will not be drawn to one who is crude, boastful, overbearing, thoughtless, even cruel. A son whose father treats his mother with chivalry will treat his wife so, almost invariably.

A father and mother who are kind to their own parents, and patient with them as they grow dependent with age, will most certainly receive kindness from their own children in their own advancing years.

In prayer and in patient observation, he studies his children. What he wants for them is whatever God made them for- whatever their abilities and talents and inclinations suggest as most suitable for them. What he does do is to create, as far as it is within his power, conditions in which they will come under the best influences, and meet the most desirable people-desirable not for wealth or position, but for character and virtue. The wise father will set before his children the various possibilities for the future, urging that all the possibilities be considered.

What the wise father wants is what is best for his sons and daughters-not what might cater to his pride or his ambition.
From the first toddling steps his little ones take, the wise father begins to help them grow away from dependence on him, and toward self-determination, although always under God. He does not cling to them or make them instruments of his self-esteem.

The father will pause sometimes to consider St. Joseph. He was the father of Christ in all but physical generation. His dedication to Mary and Jesus was total and totally unselfish.He was humble, patient, courteous, considerate, quick to love and praise, slow to blame and condemn. He was a man guarding against dangers to his family, a man turning to God for guidance in the perplexities of life. This is the foremost need of a family-the prayers of the father; for those are the prayers that most affect the whole life of the family, not only by bringing God's blessing, but by making a man the kind of father whose example and influence make the family all that it ought to be.


Bernard O'Connor, Imprimatur:
Archbishop Justin D. Simonds, 30th April, 1965
.

1. Fatherhood as a path to sanctity
2. Fatherhood- a life of prayer and servitude
How to deal with our imperfections?

"We are miserable creatures, who can scarcely do any good. But God, who is infinitely good, is content with our little works, and the preparation of our heart is agreeable to Him."

Psalm 9:39

•You complain of the many imperfections and defects to be found in your life, contrary to your desire of perfection and to the purity of the love of God.
We must however carry ourselves about with us until God carries us to Heaven; and so long as we carry ourselves, we shall have nothing to boast of.
God does not love our imperfections nor venial sins, but He loves us much notwithstanding them. As the weakness and infirmity of an infant displease it's mother, yet she does no cease to love it, but loves it tenderly and compassionately; so God, while He does not approve of our imperfections or venial sins, ceases not to love us tenderly.

"God takes pleasure to see you take your little steps; and like a good father who holds his child by the hand, He will accommodate His steps to yours and will be content to go no faster than you. Why do you worry?"

St Francis de Sales

•We must have patience, and not expect to cure in one day the many bad habits that we have contracted, through the little care we have taken of our spiritual health.
God has indeed cured some persons speedily, without a vestige of their malady remaining, as in the case of Magdalen, who, in a moment, was changed from a sink of corruption into a fountain of perfection, and was never afterwards troubled.
But the same God left, a considerable time after their conversion, in many of His disciples, marks of their former inclinations: and all for their greater good.

"When you encounter difficulties and contradictions, do not try to break them, but bend them with gentleness and time."

St Francis de Sales

"The best penance is to have patience with the Sorrows God permits. A very good penance is to dedicate oneself to fulfill the duties of everyday with exactitude and to study and work with all our strength."

St Peter Damian

"One should not say that it is impossible to reach a virtuous life; but one should say that it is not easy. Nor do those who have reached it find it easy to maintain."

St. Anthony of the Desert

•The faults into which we fall often give us place to great acts of virtue, which, otherwise, we should never have had occasion to practice, and God permits our faults for this end.
Never permit your mind to think too much on its miseries; leave them to God; He will do something with them.

"The fault is committed by a sudden impulse; the reparation is made with reflection, by the victory over one self, and with a full and deliberate will. The latter is an act much more agreeable to God, than the former as a fault was disagreeable to Him."

St. Francis de Sales
The people will be like their priests.

"There is an adage in the Church that confirms this judgement: "A holy priest will have a fervent parish; a fervent priest, a mediocre one; a mediocre priest, a bad one; and a bad priest will have nothing left.' Always one level less!"

Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre
Mental Prayer
according to St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori


Chapter 3. The Ends of Mental Prayer


WE OUGHT NOT TO SEEK IN MENTAL PRAYER
SPIRITUAL CONSOLATIONS

We must apply ourselves to meditation, not for the sake of spiritual consolations, but chiefly in order to learn what is the will of God concerning us. "Speak Lord," said Samuel to God, "for Thy servant heareth" (1 Kings 3: 9). Lord, make me to know what Thou wilt, that I may do it. Some persons continue meditation as long as consolations continue; but when these cease, they leave off meditation.

It is true that God is accustomed to comfort His beloved souls at the time of meditation, and to give them some foretaste of the delights He prepares in Heaven for those who love Him.

These are things which the lovers of the world do not comprehend; they who have not taste except for earthly delights despise those which are celestial. Oh, if they were wise, how surely would they leave their pleasures to shut themselves in their closets, to speak alone with God!

Meditation is nothing more than a converse between the soul and God; the soul pours forth to Him its affections, its desires, its fears, its requests, and God speaks to the heart, causing it to know His goodness, and the love which He bears it, and what it must do to please Him.

But these delights are not constant, and for the most part, holy souls experience much dryness of spirit in meditation. "With dryness and temptations," says St. Teresa, "the Lord makes proof of those who love Him." And she adds, "Even if this dryness lasts through life, let not the soul leave off meditation; the time will come when all will be well rewarded."

The time of dryness is the time for gaining the greatest rewards; and when we find ourselves apparently without fervor, without good desires, and, as it were, unable to do a good act, let us humble ourselves and resign ourselves, for this very meditation will be more fruitful than others.

It is enough then to say, if we can say nothing more, "O Lord, help me, have mercy on me, abandon me not!" Let us also have recourse to our comforter, the most holy Mary. Happy he who does not leave off meditation in the hour of desolation.

#stalphonsus #mentalprayer
Levels of Prayer

St. Teresa of Avila taught that the intensity of one's prayer life coincides with the intensity of one's charity. This is based on solid theology and was confirmed by St. Pius X who taught that the grades of prayer represent the grades of elevation or ascent to Christian perfection. In other words, where you are in your prayer life is a gauge of where you are in your spiritual life. You cannot advance in Christian perfection without advancing in grades of prayer.

“…pray, and never give up praying. If you pray, you will be certainly saved; if you do not pray, you will be certainly damned.” – St. Alphonsus De Liguori’s Conclusion to a Short Treatise on Prayer

The Church teaches us that there are three major expressions (or forms) of prayer – Vocal, Meditation, and Contemplation.
Through the lives of the Saints and their works, and the efforts of theologians, it is understood that there are nine levels or grades of prayer:

1.Vocal Prayer
___
2. Mental Prayer
3. Affective Prayer
4. Acquired Recollection
5. Infused Contemplation
6. Prayer of Quiet
___
7. Simple Union
8. Conforming Union
9. Transforming Union

Notice the lowest form of prayer is Vocal Prayer, meaning using words either audibly or mentally, whereas mental prayer is primarily in the intellect, focusing on God or meditating on some mystery without words of any kind. The Holy Rosary combines the first two levels through vocal prayers while meditating on the mysteries of our Lord (Mental Prayer). The saints tell us that Mental Prayer is the gateway to all the higher forms of prayer, and the higher you ascend also corresponds to your progress in virtue.


Church describes vocal prayer: “Vocal prayer associates the body with the interior prayer of the heart. Even the most interior prayer, however, cannot dispense with vocal prayer. In any case, it must always spring from a personal faith. With the Our Father Jesus has taught us a perfect form of vocal prayer.”

Meditation is a higher form of prayer than vocal prayer as it utilizes the power of your imagination with focus on holy truths. Meditation has been referred to as one of the more difficult forms of prayer as many have not yet mastered their imagination and distraction becomes common-place. The Compendium of the Catholic Church states: “Meditation is a prayerful reflection that begins above all in the Word of God in the Bible. Meditation engages though, imagination, emotion and desire in order to deepen our faith, convert our heart and fortify our will to follow Christ. It is a first step toward the union of love with God.” Or as St. Padre Pio has said, “The final purpose of meditation is the love of God and one’s neighbor. Love the first with all your soul and without reservation, love the second as another self, and you will have arrived at the final purpose of meditation.” And this beloved saint, knowing how difficult meditative prayer gives us hope in saying, “When you do not succeed in meditating well do not, for this reason, cease to do your duty. If there are many distractions do not lose heart. Make a meditation on patience; you will profit all the same. Fix the time, the length of your meditation, and do not rise from your place until you have finished it.

Contemplative prayer is a simple gaze upon God in silence and love. It is a gift of God, a moment of pure faith during which the one praying seeks Christ, surrenders himself to the loving will of the Father, and places his being under the action of the Holy Spirit. Saint Teresa of Avila defines contemplative prayer as the intimate sharing of friendship, “in which time is frequently taken to be along with God who we know loves us.”

https://youtu.be/WeOLenpKta8

#mentalprayer
On the authorities in the Church and fraternal correction, p.II

"To presume oneself to be simply better than one's prelate, would seem to savor of presumtuous pride; but there is no presumption in thinking oneself better in some respect, because, in this life, no man is without some fault. We must also remember that when a man reproves his prelate charitably, it does not follow that he thinks himself any better, but merely that he offers his help to one who "being in a higher position among you, is therefore in greater danger.""

Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica II-II Q33, Art4, Reply to obj. 3


"The reprehension was just and useful, and the reason for it was not light: there was a danger for the preservation of Gospel truth. The way it took place was appropriate, since it was public and manifest. For this reason, St. Paul writes: 'I spoke to Cephas,' that is, Peter, 'before everyone,' since the simulation practiced by St. Peter was fraught with danger to everyone."

St. Thomas Aquinas: Summa Theologiae, IIa IIae, Q. 33, A. 4

"To withstand anyone in public exceeds the mode of fraternal correction , and so Paul would not have withstood Peter then, unless he were in some way his equal as regards the defence of the faith. But one who is not an equal can reprove privately and respectfully..It must be observed, however, that if the faith were endangered, a subject ought to rebuke his prelate even publicly. Hence, Paul, who was Peter's subject, rebuked him in public, on account of the imminent danger of scandal concerning faith, and, as the gloss of Augustine says on Gal.2:11: "Peter gave an example to superiors, that if in any time they should happen to stray from the straight path, they should not disdain to be reproved by their subjects."

St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica II-II, Q33, Art4, Reply to obj.2
The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass

Thomas Aquinas identifies four obligations that every man owes to God indefinitely


1. To praise and honour His infinite majesty
2. To satisfy for the many sins commited against that infinite majesty
3. To thank Him for all benefits received
4. To supplicate Him as the giver of all graces


These four obligations correspond perfectly to the Four Ends of the Sacrifice the Mass

1. Adoration
2. Atonement
3. Thanksgiving
4. Petition


The Four Ends of the Mass are the same four obligations that we owe to God. This is why St. Thomas identified the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass as the most efficacious method of paying the four great debts owed by us to God. St. Peter Julain Eymard says in his book 'The Real Presence': let us pray as He does according to the Four Ends of the Sacrifice; this form of prayer sums up religious worship and entails the practice of every virtue."

Mass is the highest and holiest act and greatest prayer of the Church because it is the action of Christ Himself. When we unite ourselves and our prayers to Jesus' sacrifice on the cross at Calvary during every mass, truly that is the most efficacious method of prayer.

"All the good works in the world are not equal to the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass because they are works of men; but the Mass is the work of God. Martyrdom is nothing in comparison for it is but the sacrifice of man to God; but the Mass is the sacrifice of God for man."

St. John Vianney

#mass
the_problem_of_the_liturgical_reform(1).pdf
971.7 KB
"The Problem of the Liturgical Reform" - a theological and Liturgical Study

The Society of Saint Pius X
Angelus Press

"The missal of Pope Paul VI, because of its serious theological defects, does not have and cannot have the character of a true and binding law. While waiting for the legislator to publish the neces-
sary theological, liturgical, and canonical clarifications, one can in good conscience use the missal revised by St. Pius V."

#novusordo #mass
Forwarded from ♰ Traditional Latin Mass ♰
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
The Latin ♰ Sancta Missa ♰ Explained for Priests
Forwarded from ♰ Traditional Latin Mass ♰
The Latin Mass Explained and Demonstrated for Priests.mkv
1.4 GB
The Latin ♰ Sancta Missa ♰ Explained for Priests
Forwarded from ♰ Traditional Latin Mass ♰
A Pious Reflection on the Latin Mass the Faithful May Use to Derive Spiritual Fruit
J. R. R. Tolkien’s Ancestry in Gdańsk, Poland. From 1724 in Gdańsk to the Coming to London in 1770

J. R. R. Tolkien’s (1892–1973) ancestry has been an obscure matter. From the official biographies of the famous Oxford professor and author we have known only about Tolkien’s great-grandparents and about the general direction of the Tolkien family’s migration in the eighteenth century described as „Saxony”. Ryszard Derdziński has found out J. R. R. Tolkien’s great-great-grandfather’s roots. Discovering crucial genealogical documents from London, Gdańsk (Poland) and Kreuzburg (East Prussia) ie. church records, a Parliament bill, newspaper news, entries in the books from that age etc. Derdziński has proved that John Benjamin Tolkien (1752–1719), J. R. R. Tolkien’s ancestor who lived and died in London and was a watch- and clock-maker, was born in Gdańsk in June 1752. His brother was Daniel Gottlieb Tolkien from London who also was born in Polish Gdańsk in July 1746. They emigrated from Gdańsk to London in the years 1766–1772. Their father was Christian Tolkien (1706–1791), a craftsman from Gdańsk, brother of a Gdańsk furrier, Michael Tolkien (1708–1795). Both Christian and Michael were born in a little town Kreuzburg in East Prussia (now Slavskoye in Kaliningrad Oblast). Derdziński has found there at least four generations of this line of the Tolkien family and the first known Tolkien from Kreuzburg was Friedrich Tolkien from 1614. The article shows also the genesis of the Tolkien family name and locates its beginning in the fourteenth century and a small village Tolkynen (today Tołkiny in Poland).

Author:" There are quotes from Tolkien that show his dream to know the prehistoric roots of his male lineage. Today we make this dream come true by
researching the Tolkien Y-DNA."

"Anyway I like to go back - and not with race only, or culture only, or language; but with all three. I wish I could go back with the three that are mixed in us."
-J.R.R. Tolkien

FamilyTreeDNA (Big Y) and YFull confirm that Eric Tolkien's haplogroup is R-Y42738. It was supposed to arise between 1800 and 3300 years ago (averaged 2500 years ago, i.e around 480 BC, in the Iron Age).

R-Y42738 is a subbranch of the great Indo-European haplogroup R1a, which has its origins 24,000 years ago in the Paleolithic mammoth hunting community of present-day Siberia (see the so-called "Mal'ta Boy"). From R1a in the Neolithic, an ancestral line with the R-Z92 mutation was separated, which we find mainly among the descendants of the Balts and Eastern Slavs. From R-Z92 in the Bronze Age, the pre-Baltic group R-YP350, which today mainly includes descendants of the (Baltic) Old Prussians and Yotvingians, was separated. A sub-branch of R-YP350 is R-Y42738 (which today includes the Tolkien family, the Derdzinski family and the Kacsóh family from Hungary, and from which in the Iron Age there were also separated sub-branches, which today include families from Norway, Finland and Belarus, which are probably related to with the history of the Baltic Sea Vikings).

Today we know the approximate history of Tolkien's male line over the last several tens of thousands of years. It's worth taking a look at this map by typing "Y42738" in the box
http://scaledinnovation.com/gg/snpTracker.html

•Sources:

pdf version
http://www.elendilion.pl/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/TolkienAncestry.pdf

published article(preview)
https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=720195

author's blog:(article-Tolkien | the confirmed haplogroup is R-Y42738)
https://tolkniety.blogspot.com/2021/08/tolkien-confirmed-haplogroup-is-y42738.html

author's blog:(Why are we doing Tolkien's DNA testing?)
http://tolkniety.blogspot.com/2021/05/why-are-we-doing-tolkien-dna-testing.html?m=1

about the author of the article
http://www.elvish.org/gwaith/biography.htm

reading material:

Old Prussians
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Prussians

Warmians
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warmians

Yotvingians
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yotvingians

Tołkiny village
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/To%C5%82kiny

#tolkien
"Three men, two worlds, one cause"

On bishop Wawrzyniec Gościcki, Gilbert Keith Chesterton, John Ronald Reuel Tolkien and the case of distributist economics

(I've come across this very interesting article on one of the Polish conservative blogs and decided to share it here. Excuse the quality of the translation, I helped myself with an internet translator, which isn't ideal, especially given the style in which the original was written.)

It should be mentioned that the writer of these words has two fundamental ideological passions, these being the Polish political tradition (let us call it Sarmatian) and Catholic Social Teaching. How to combine these into a coherent whole? It will take two different political systems and cultures, which are only seemingly distant from each other (although in fact the capitals of the two countries in question are separated by more than 1 600 kilometres and a lot of water), because they are linked by a certain thread of understanding, which is easy to spot if one only cares to look closer.

1. (III)

Wawrzyniec Gościcki, bishop and political thinker. This is the third, or rather the first name, alongside Stanisław Orzechowski and Andrzej Frycz Modrzewski, to be mentioned when recalling the founders of Polish political thought during the most glorious period in the history of our state - the Sarmatian Commonwealth. Who would have thought that the work of a Polish bishop from Goślice near Płock would inspire William Shakespeare himself[1]? We are, of course, talking about the treatise "On the Perfect Senator"[2]. There, Grzymała[3] encapsulated the essence of the political ideal of a mixed monarchy, a system of government divided between the King, the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies, which there is no need to explain here. Let it suffice to say that those who malign the Sarmatian state by calling it a crowned republic are not at all doing the enthusiasts of this system a disservice, as there is absolutely nothing to be offended about. A Pole is a republican, a Pole is a monarchist, a Pole is a democrat. There is no contradiction here, in fact it is an organic combination of political phenomena that once brought the Sarmatians the opportunity to have a million square kilometre empire. It is worth mentioning, as a curiosity, that this vastness was managed by an administration of about a thousand officials (an internet search reveals that today there are about 250,000 of them working on less than 313,000 square kilometres).

"This type of state was not without reason considered the most just. For as on the strings a concordant sound is produced by the union of the various tones: the highest, lowest and middle states, as Cicero says, as if from the tones, a harmony is evoked which in the state constitutes the strongest and tightest knot of security for all. I, too, consider as the best such a polity, which consists first of good and eminent citizens of virtue, and then of these three states of men, the king, the senators and the people[4]."

There are two fundamental features of the political system of the Republic: decentralisation of power and locality of representation[5].

As for the former, it is not contained in the age-old fear of the Polish nobility of absolutum dominium or the systemic logic enshrined in Nihil novi. The phenomenon of decentralisation is based on the 'grantiveness' of power.